Sin Sodt - revisited

Long distance relationships, mixed relationships etc...

Sin Sodt - revisited

PostAuthor: Ricky » July 31, 2006, 10:52 am

I thought you may be interested in this story.

Over a year ago when living in Phuket I met two sisters from Udon Thani who were working in a bar in Patong. Because I knew I was about to move to Udon I spent some time chatting to them, asking them about Udon etc.

Well recently, quite by chance, I met the younger of the two girls, in the Charoensri shopping complex in Udon. We sat and chatted together for some 10 minutes, during which time she told me that whilst working in Patong, she had met a Swiss man, a doctor, and that they had since married.

Being curious I enquired about a possible sin sodt and she told me he had paid 250,000 baht plus 5 baht in gold. :shock: And before you ask, none of which was returned the next day!!!! As I understood things, this young lady had a basic education - I doubt she even reached high school, and had/has little job prospects. She was average in terms of her looks, though has a pleasant personality.

She was currently waiting for her husband to return from Switzerland and arrange a visa for her to go there to live with him. Her older sister is evidently on holiday with a friend in Phuket.

Oh and guess what, the young lady was accompanied by an older, much less attractive lady, whom she introduced as her Aunt and for whom she was actively seeking a farang boyfriend.
I wonder why!! :lol:
User avatar
Ricky
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 5010
Joined: October 2, 2005, 12:19 pm
Location: En route

PostAuthor: Prenders88 » July 31, 2006, 11:12 am

Wow!!
The girl and her family have hit the jackpot \:D/

We have a village house near Bandung, when we go back to the "village" I always get asked if we can find a husband. Photo's are put under our noses. A few cases the girls have been to Uni or college. But for most who have had a basic education there are scant oppotunities to be had. You need a decree to work in a Hotel reception/Bank/Office in Thailand, for most with a basic education it's low paid menial work. :(
Prenders88
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 1692
Joined: July 7, 2005, 12:51 am
Location: I made my excuses and left

Re: Sin Sodt - revisited

PostAuthor: Papy Ion » July 31, 2006, 11:13 am

arjay wrote:...

Being curious I enquired about a possible sin sodt and she told me he had paid 250,000 baht plus 5 baht in gold. :shock: And before you ask, none of which was returned the next day!!!! As I understood things, this young lady had a basic education - I doubt she even reached high school, and had/has little job prospects. She was average in terms of her looks, though has a pleasant personality.

...


I know for sure that it was exactly the same figures and amount of gold recently for a German 49-year old gentleman to marry a divorced 31-year old (physically average in my opinion) thai lady, mother of two children! :shock:
User avatar
Papy Ion
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 98
Joined: June 22, 2006, 2:50 pm

PostAuthor: Ricky » July 31, 2006, 11:20 am

I know for sure that it was exactly the same figures and amount of gold recently for a German 49-year old gentleman to marry a divorced 31-year old (physically average in my opinion) thai lady, mother of two children!


I wonder if it's the same village!! :lol: Word travels quickly round here!! :lol: :lol:
User avatar
Ricky
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 5010
Joined: October 2, 2005, 12:19 pm
Location: En route

PostAuthor: Papy Ion » July 31, 2006, 11:28 am

arjay wrote:
I know for sure that it was exactly the same figures and amount of gold recently for a German 49-year old gentleman to marry a divorced 31-year old (physically average in my opinion) thai lady, mother of two children!


I wonder if it's the same village!! :lol: Word travels quickly round here!! :lol: :lol:



I think that this lady is from a village called "Ban Kut Phung" (spelling?) in the Suwannakuha district.
User avatar
Papy Ion
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 98
Joined: June 22, 2006, 2:50 pm

PostAuthor: beer monkey » July 31, 2006, 2:51 pm

Prenders88 wrote:Wow!!
The girl and her family have hit the jackpot \:D/

when we go back to the "village" I always get asked if we can find a husband. Photo's are put under our noses. :(


same happens to me, but am not interested, i just smile and say i don't know anyone.don't want to get involved.
User avatar
beer monkey
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 12738
Joined: January 1, 2006, 8:08 am

PostAuthor: Ricky » July 31, 2006, 4:37 pm

Wow!!
The girl and her family have hit the jackpot

when we go back to the "village" I always get asked if we can find a husband. Photo's are put under our noses.

i just smile and say i don't know anyone.don't want to get involved.


I suppose we could always say, (I know someone very suitable, but) Sin Sodts are against our religion!! 8) :lol:
User avatar
Ricky
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 5010
Joined: October 2, 2005, 12:19 pm
Location: En route

PostAuthor: BKKSTAN » July 31, 2006, 4:46 pm

No one in the village ever asks me to find them a husband!Probably because I never paid any Sin Sod.I explained to them that Sin Sod is only customary for the womens first marriage and even then,no sin sod if the parents are dead!
User avatar
BKKSTAN
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 8370
Joined: July 18, 2005, 12:55 pm
Location: Nong Khai

PostAuthor: laphanphon » August 1, 2006, 2:48 pm

what did old PB say, "there's one born every minute"
laphanphon
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 4864
Joined: July 4, 2005, 7:47 pm

PostAuthor: BKKSTAN » August 1, 2006, 3:55 pm

When I met my wife,she had been making about 6000 baht a month working 7 days a week 12+ hrs a day.She was 27-28 and this was her highest monthly income of entire working life.She had a daughter still living with family back in the village.To get her to go on a date with me,I told her that I would cover her loss of income from sales of her food.200 baht when I could get her to close the store.I bought her small gifts as time went on.when I asked her if she would like to try to have a live together relationship and she finally agreed,I asked her what she would like,gold ring,bracelet etc.etc.''Really''?''Yes''!''Could I have a diamond''?''Sure''!33,000 baht,never seen anyone so happy!

When we went to the village,everyone started telling her how stupid she was.Should have got gold,build a house,how much sin sod he will pay,how much does he pay you every month,yada yada yada.She hadn't lived in the village since she left her village husband 7 years earlier and They had never seemed to concerned about her welfare before during that eventful marriage,nor while she was working in Bangkok.But it did make for some new discussions between us about money!Sin sod was ruled out by her,""but what happens if we break up?''''If you never lie to me,ever,and either one of us decides that we don't want to stay together,I promise that I will see that you are back in business and have savings equal to the 6000 baht a month''!! ''OK''.We have been together 6 years.Got married 6 months after we started going together.Took her that long to feel secure,as we had known each other for over a year before I asked her out.My ex and I lived in the neighborhood , were her regulars customers,and she was worried that I still might want the ex!

She told me''Parents already got 10,000 baht sin sod from 1rst husband'',''And they are dead,anyway''!Didn't hurt our relationship a little bit!!
User avatar
BKKSTAN
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 8370
Joined: July 18, 2005, 12:55 pm
Location: Nong Khai

PostAuthor: Ricky » September 4, 2006, 6:44 pm

I often pick up bits of gossip through my GF. The latest I've just heard is that a Thai friend of a friend is trying to find a farang husband and an Internet shop in a local BIG store is doing the emailing etc for them. They are setting the sin sodt at 200K and the Internet shop want 100K as a type of "arrangement fee". That assumes that they succeed in finding someone on those terms!! :shock:

Also, the friends involved all agree that the farang should not already be living in Thailand, because if he lives here already he will know too much!! :roll: To me if someone lives here already that should really be an advantage, because you should be able to assume that he knows something about Thai people and culture and has been able to adapt Ok. :)

Also a brother of one of those same girls families is shortly to get married to a Thai, and they initially asked for a sin sodt of 100K, but as he, understandably, doesn't have that sort of money a figure of 40K has been agreed upon! :D
User avatar
Ricky
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 5010
Joined: October 2, 2005, 12:19 pm
Location: En route

PostAuthor: beer monkey » September 4, 2006, 7:17 pm

arjay wrote:I often pick up bits of gossip through my GF. The latest I've just heard is that a Thai friend of a friend is trying to find a farang husband and an Internet shop in a local BIG store is doing the emailing etc for them. They are setting the sin sodt at 200K and the Internet shop want 100K as a type of "arrangement fee".


200k and he is paying the Internet shop,and probably don't even know it
Mmm 100k for a few translated e-mails.....feel sorry for that farang, she sounds like a real good catch.(but he might be worse i suppose)
still he may be a new member on here now or soon, so maybe he will spot this. !
User avatar
beer monkey
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 12738
Joined: January 1, 2006, 8:08 am

PostAuthor: Ricky » September 4, 2006, 7:19 pm

Sorry, I misled you there. The shop want 100K of the 200K sin sodt. :oops:
User avatar
Ricky
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 5010
Joined: October 2, 2005, 12:19 pm
Location: En route

PostAuthor: beer monkey » September 4, 2006, 7:25 pm

still 100k for some spoof e-mails translated in to engleesh.... :shock:
User avatar
beer monkey
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 12738
Joined: January 1, 2006, 8:08 am

PostAuthor: willyboy » September 4, 2006, 9:20 pm

As a relative newbie to the Forum, I would like to throw in a few thoughts about farang relationships with Thai girls.

Firstly, I saw a comment that it was easy and usually preferable to walk away from a failing relationship, recognizing that it’s only money that is being lost. I would agree we do need to be sufficiently objective to recognize the signs and then to initiate plans to walk away. But one of the bigger issues for older farangs is that often much capital has been sunk into a particular relationship/situation and whilst assuming one has an on-going source of income such as a pension, I would point out it is very difficult to replace capital already expended. If an individual moves through 2 or 3 failed relationships his capital is likely to be quickly eroded.

It is therefore important to go slowly and be very sure of your relationship before committing significant funds.

I suspect that many farangs still live in farangland and see/visit their TW’s/TGF’s maybe 3 times a year, for 2 or 3 weeks at a time. In my view that simply is not sufficient to know them well enough, or to justify committing significant funds to purchase houses and land etc. You really have to live with someone for an extended period to get to know the real person – even more important because of the large cultural differences.

Something else that irritates me, prompted by comments I have heard, along the lines of: “Has he bought you a house yet?” and “Oh, if mine didn’t, I wouldn’t stay with him!” She is talking about her husband, whom she allegedly loves. There seems to be an ever increasing assumption with so many Thai girls that Ok if I have a farang BF he will buy me a house and a pickup and maybe one for my parents too. A nice idea, but a rather presumptuous perspective!

Let’s stop for a moment and view the alternative perspective. What happens if, with her 1.5 children and lack of income and job prospects, she is lucky enough to find a Thai BF, which is unlikely? Would he have the funds to buy her a house and vehicle outright? No, he would not. If he did, he would most likely be moving in different circles and looking at someone else.

So what gives this lady the right to expect, if not demand, that her new farang BF buys her a house and car, AND often in the first 3 months they’ve known each other?

Just stop and think for a minute. If boy and girl meet in farang land (or indeed normally in LOS) they pool their resources and work towards buying a house together. This normally involves them both working and saving a deposit and then buying the house by way of a mortgage/bank loan over many years. There is no outright purchase of such a valuable asset as a house. Indeed they may well spend most of their lives working and paying to achieve that. Why then should little Poo Ying from Udon expect virtually all of it to be laid on her plate, and almost up front?

Ok you might argue, yes, but we’re not talking of a 23 year old starting out on life’s journey. In most instances the farang man has already worked for a large part of his life to build up his assets (and lost half of them to his ex back in farangland). So he now has available funds. Well, think again. If he was to re-marry in farangland, the same principles as above would apply, in that they would each pool what assets they had accumulated and see what they could buy in the way or a house together, and it may well still involve a loan for some part of the funds.

The same applies to the sin sot. Would a divorced lady, age 28 (that’s over the hill for Thai men), with little education, few work skills, 2 children, and from a farming village, really expect to get a dowry of more than 40K baht? I doubt it, unless a farang comes along and pays 400K baht!! But that was last week. What will this week bring?

What has happened? Is it an increase in greed and communication? Has the third question after “What’s your name?” become “How much will you give and what will you buy me, if we get married?”?

If a relationship is based on: “Ok you buy me land, a house and a 4 x 4 and then maybe I’ll love you”, in my view the relationship is doomed from the start. There should initially be an “Ok I like you and want to get to know you more. If things go well and we love each other then Ok we may want to get married. Then as time unfolds, things are going well, I will naturally want to do the best for my beloved and provide her with security for her future. I do feel we are all too often putting the cart before the horse (or allowing the cart to be put before the horse on our behalf) and in doing so setting a precedent for all, particularly those following later. I understand Thais have very long courtships and they are from the same culture and know each other better than we who are from a different culture. So why do we jump in so quickly, often after only 3 months?

Come on guys, what is this? Are you indulging in “one-upmanship”? Who can pay the biggest “sin sod”? Who can buy the largest and most expensive house in Issan? It’s getting to be like an auction! Remember the bigger the outlay, the harder the fall!

Back up a bit. Shouldn’t we be saying, Ok we live together and if all is good after the first year, I’ll pay the first instalment of the sin sod (if indeed there needs to be one). If after 2 years all is well, then I’ll pay the second instalment and maybe we should be looking to buy a house and home for the future. Surely, he who has the money should be calling the tune?

The above said, conversely I would be the first to agree, that we the farang men should not and cannot expect that by offering to buy these things that it will in turn buy the love of our partner.

If I may quote from a recent Forum posting:-

Where the equation went wrong is the expectation they each had from the exchange. He thought his buying all these things would BUY her everlasting devotion etc etc. She thought his buying them for her would enable her to love him. They were both wrong and in a way you could accuse both of being selfish thinking they could put a monetary value on each others love.

May I also add, I realize that many farangs have met, married and been together with their TW’s for a long time and have provided for them as they would wish and as one would consider appropriate. I totally endorse such action and am not seeking to undermine a long standing, well established and trusting relationship. My points relate to the expectations of the currently available girls, and to the visiting farang who suddenly thinks he has met Miss Right, at a local drinking establishment and then before you know it, has committed a large part of his life’s assets to someone he barely really knows.
willyboy
nongkhaimap.com
nongkhaimap.com
 
Posts: 30
Joined: August 28, 2006, 6:56 am
Location: Down at the billabong, waltzing with matilda

Next

Return to Relationships

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

  • Advertisement